The First of Many Cellar Tasting Updates
By jason on Feb 24, 2009 in Featured, Reviews
Hello everyone. I’m hoping to get one of these tasting updates banged out each week until I finally get current. It’s going to be a long haul, but I’ll get there.
In the meantime, I want to make sure everyone knows just how well the Le Merle from North Coast brewing has been doing - it’s AWESOME. Easily one of the biggest improvements I’ve seen in the cellar. Be sure to add this brew to your collection if you’re able to, I guarantee you won’t regret it.
Stone Old Guardian Barleywine ‘08 (Six Months) - Holding up well, still delicious! There is a hint of “old hop” flavor starting to develop, but it’s just contributing positively to the brews’ complexity for now.
Avery 14th Anniversary Ale (One Year) - Changes, changes, changes. This brew can’t stay still. Right now it feels like a porter - there’s definite notes of toffee, raisin, and light chocolate.
Avery Samuel’s Oak-Aged Ale (One Year) - All of the complexity of this brew has slipped right away. All that’s left is a thick, syrupy, oak-flavored sugar bomb.
Corsendonk Abbey Brown Ale (One Year) - No off-flavors to speak of. That’s good, right? Maybe - but unfortunately there are almost no flavors AT ALL to speak of. Definitely not a brew to cellar.
Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale (One Year) - The pumpkin is pretty much all gone. There’s still some nice spice flavor, but this brew is just barely drinkable.
Weyerbacher Insanity (Six Months) - Much the same except for one major difference - the alcohol burn. It’s pretty much gone. This brew is definitely more drinkable now.
North Coast Le Merle (Six Months) - Just awesome. Awesome. Light and zippy, fruity with an earthy finish.
Stoudt’s Triple (One Year) - Bright and fruity, much like before. The big mystery here is that this tasting was actually sweeter then the six-month tasting, where I had found that the brew had noticeably dried up.
Jason
I recently tried a fresh bottle of Samuel’s and found it undrinkable with sweetness. I’m glad I only bought the one. It makes me appreciate the likes of Thomas Hardy’s and JW Lee’s even more!
Just a heads up, the link for Insanity points to the Imperial Pumpkin page.
Tim | Feb 25, 2009 | Reply
Thanks for the heads up on the link Tim. I kinda wish I only bought one of the Samuel’s too!
jason | Feb 25, 2009 | Reply
Thanks for the Weyerbacher review - I have two Imperial Pumpkin Ales that are about 2-years old, so I’ll lower (or remove) my expectations for them.
Also, just opened an ‘05 Brooklyn Black Chocoalte Stout - 4 years is a bit too long for this one. It opened with barely a hiss, poured with no head or other indication of carbonation. Kind of smelled vinegary. It was drinkable, but no where near what it used to be at 1-year old.
Jim L | Sep 22, 2009 | Reply